Looking for a Mercian Accountants Alternative for Your Agency?
Mercian Accountants is a Shrewsbury-based firm with experience serving digital and creative agencies. If you’re exploring specialist alternatives, here’s how Alto compares.
What Mercian Accountants Offers
Mercian Accountants is based in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, and provides accountancy services to a range of businesses including digital marketing and design agencies. Their partners have experience in the marketing agency landscape, with some having run their own agency previously.
They offer bookkeeping, payroll management, year-end accounts, Corporation Tax returns, VAT returns, management accounts, pension planning, and tax planning. The firm emphasises transparent, fixed monthly pricing without hidden costs, plain English communication, and cloud-based solutions that give clients remote access to their financial records.
- Based in Shrewsbury, Shropshire, serving clients across the UK
- Partners with agency management experience
- Bookkeeping, payroll, year-end accounts, VAT, and Corporation Tax
- Management accounts and pension planning
- Fixed monthly pricing with no hidden costs
- Cloud-based accounting for remote access
- Network of trusted banking and legal professionals
How Alto’s Specialisation Goes Deeper
Mercian Accountants serves the creative sector as one of several industries, bringing practical experience from partners who have worked in agencies. Alto takes this a step further by working exclusively with agencies — every client, every process, and every tool is built around the specific financial patterns of marketing, creative, and digital businesses.
This exclusive focus means Alto’s approach to revenue recognition, cash flow forecasting, and tax planning is calibrated to how agencies actually operate: the distinction between retainer and project income, the correct treatment of media passthrough, IR35 compliance for contractor-heavy teams, and identifying R&D tax credit opportunities in creative and technology work.
- Agency-only practice — 100% of clients are agencies
- Revenue recognition across retainer, project, and media passthrough models
- IR35 compliance framework for agencies engaging freelancers and contractors
- R&D tax credit identification for creative processes and proprietary tools
- Cash flow forecasting built around agency revenue cycles
- Free calculators: salary optimisation, profitability, runway, VAT, and IR35
- ACCA-chartered registered practice
Key Differences at a Glance
Both firms understand the creative sector and offer fixed-fee pricing. The differences are in depth of agency focus and the specialist tools and advisory available.
| Feature | Mercian Accountants | Alto |
|---|---|---|
| Industry focus | Multiple sectors including digital and creative agencies | Marketing, creative, and digital agencies exclusively |
| Agency experience | Partners have run their own agency | Entire practice built around agency financial patterns |
| Location | Shrewsbury, Shropshire | Remote-first, UK-wide |
| Media passthrough | Standard VAT and compliance services | Specialist media passthrough treatment and principal vs agent VAT advice |
| IR35 | Handles freelancer and contractor variables | Dedicated IR35 compliance framework with free IR35 calculator |
| R&D tax credits | Tax planning services | Proactive R&D credit identification for creative and technology work |
| Free tools | Cloud-based accounting access | Interactive calculators for salary, profitability, runway, VAT, and IR35 |
When to Choose Which
Mercian Accountants is a good option if you value working with practitioners who have hands-on agency management experience, if your agency is based in the Midlands and you prefer a regional firm, or if you want straightforward, jargon-free accounting with cloud-based access and a trusted professional network.
Alto may be a better fit if you want an accountant whose entire practice is structured around agencies — not just experienced with them, but exclusively serving them. If your agency deals with complex revenue structures (retainer plus project plus media passthrough) or if you want proactive R&D tax credit identification and free diagnostic tools, Alto is designed for that.
Both Firms Embrace Cloud Accounting
One area of alignment is the commitment to cloud-based accounting. Mercian Accountants offers cloud-based solutions that give clients smartphone access to their financial records. Alto uses Xero as its primary platform, configured specifically for agency workflows with tracking categories, integrations, and reporting tailored to agency revenue structures.
The difference is in the configuration. A general cloud setup gives you access to your numbers. An agency-specific Xero setup gives you visibility into revenue by client, profitability by project, and a clear picture of cash position that accounts for the timing differences inherent in agency work.
Frequently asked questions.
Is Mercian Accountants a specialist agency accountant?
What makes Alto different from Mercian Accountants for agencies?
Does Alto work with agencies in the Midlands?
Can Alto help with pension planning like Mercian Accountants?
Which firm is better for a design agency?
We work with every creative + digital vertical.
Book a 15-minute call.
Want to see how a dedicated agency accountant compares? Book a free financial health check — no obligation.
Free financial health check